PJ Pizza & Gyros

Nestled by Port Jefferson’s ferry dock, we serve fresh, Long Island–inspired pizza, gyros, and classic eats. We offer takeout by the slice or whole pies, convenient pickup, and fast delivery—no dine-in, just great food on the go. Order online or call now to enjoy your favorites today!

Order Online
Menu
Call

Welcome to
PJ Pizza & Gyros

PJ Pizza & Gyros is your destination for fresh, Long Island–inspired pizza, authentic gyros, and classic comfort foods. We specialize in convenience—offering takeout by the slice or whole pies, easy pickup, and fast delivery right to your door.

"Best slice by the sea!"

Emma L.

Order Now
A cozy pizzeria interior with light blue, red, and yellow accents, overlooking the ferry and harbor at sunset.
A cozy pizzeria interior with light blue, red, and yellow accents, overlooking the ferry and harbor at sunset.

Our Services

Fresh, Long Island - inspired flavors served with a smile in Port Jefferson.

Our Offerings

PJ Pizza & Gyros offers a menu packed with flavor and variety for every craving. Start with crispy appetizers like mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, and jalapeño poppers, or dive into bold Buffalo wings with your favorite sauce. Indulge in hand-tossed pizzas—from classic Cheese and Sicilian to specialty creations like Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Parmigiana, and Meat Lover’s—plus gluten-free options. Explore hearty pastas, baked dishes, and savory heroes, or try our famous gyros and wraps served with fries. Don’t miss the crazy fries, sliders, empanadas, and paninis for a twist on comfort food. Planning a party? Our catering trays make feeding a crowd easy. Finish with sweet treats like cannoli, cheesecake, and fried Oreos. Whether you’re near the Port Jefferson ferry or ordering for delivery, PJ Pizza & Gyros is your go-to spot for fresh, satisfying meals

A close-up of a wood-fired pizza with bubbling cheese and fresh basil on a rustic wooden table.
A close-up of a wood-fired pizza with bubbling cheese and fresh basil on a rustic wooden table.

Authentic Gyros

A gyro sandwich filled with juicy meat, fresh veggies, and creamy tzatziki, set against a seaside backdrop.
A gyro sandwich filled with juicy meat, fresh veggies, and creamy tzatziki, set against a seaside backdrop.

Delicious Pizza

Enjoy awesome pizzas, from classic Cheese and Sicilian to specialty favorites like Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Chicken, Chicken Parmigiana, and Meat Lover’s—crafted fresh and perfect for pickup or delivery near the Port Jefferson ferry

Savor authentic gyros made with tender meat, fresh pita, and classic toppings—available as wraps, platters, or paired with fries for the perfect meal

Our Catering Platters

Make your next event unforgettable with our generous catering trays—packed with favorites like baked ziti, chicken parmigiana, and fresh salads. Call now or order online to feed your crowd with ease!

woman wearing yellow long-sleeved dress under white clouds and blue sky during daytime

The gyro here tastes like a seaside breeze—fresh, flavorful, and unforgettable!

Amy J.

A happy customer enjoying a gyro with the Port Jefferson ferry in the background on a sunny day.
A happy customer enjoying a gyro with the Port Jefferson ferry in the background on a sunny day.

PJ Pizza’s crust is perfectly crispy, reminding me of summer nights by the Long Island coast.

Mark T.

A close-up of a delicious pizza slice with melted cheese and fresh toppings, set against a light blue and red tablecloth.
A close-up of a delicious pizza slice with melted cheese and fresh toppings, set against a light blue and red tablecloth.
★★★★★
★★★★★
Order
Menu
Call
Contact

Questions? Reach out to PJ Pizza and Gyros!

Email

Phone

info@pjpizzaandgyros.com

(631) 509 5805

© Olive Mill Advertising 2025.
All rights reserved.